plate 397 · 2023 data

Poorer countries' share of science papers tripled to half

Share of the world's scientific and technical journal articles by World Bank income group, 2003–2023.

The tech race
  1. 1. China leads research in 57 of 64 critical technologies
  2. 2. China's international patent filings grew sixfold since 2010
  3. 3. Nearly half of top AI researchers studied in China
  4. 4. China's research spending rose from 12% to 88% of America's
  5. 5. China spends more importing chips than crude oil
  6. 6. Two in three working satellites are now Starlinks
  7. 7. Irish data centres now use more power than city homes
  8. 8. Indians now file more patents at home than Germans
  9. 9. India published more science papers than Germany and Britain combined
  10. 10. Brazilians now use Pix more often than all cards combined
  11. 11. Poland's digital service exports grew fivefold in a decade
  12. 12. Africa now holds 32 of the 38 mostly offline countries
  13. 13. Viet Nam climbed from 30th to fifth in computer exports
  14. 14. Caracas home internet has caught up with Mexico City's
  15. 15. Mexico replaced China as America's top computer supplier
  16. 16. India went from 2% to 42% of America's smartphone imports
  17. 17. 56 countries got their first satellite after 2010, 51 before
  18. 18. Billion-dollar digital service exporters rose from 35 to 60
  19. 19. India joined the top ten buyers of processor chips
  20. 20. Russia's share of rocket launches fell from 57% to 5%
  21. 21. Sichuan fell from first to fourth among China's computer makers
  22. 22. Companies putting satellites in orbit rose fivefold in ten years
  23. 23. GitHub developers grew fastest in poorer countries, led by Nigeria
  24. 24. Mobile data became affordable in 36 more countries since 2021
  25. 25. Viet Nam overtook Japan in consumer electronics exports
  26. 26. Countries sending people to orbit doubled, from 10 to 21
  27. 27. India rose from 21st to ninth in telecom equipment exports
  28. 28. Thirteen countries flew spacecraft beyond Earth orbit, up from six
  29. 29. Poorer countries' share of science papers tripled to half
51%

Share of the world's science papers written in low- and middle-income countries in 2023, up from 16% in 2003.

29%

China's share of the world total in 2023; without China, the poorer countries' share still rose from 9% to 22%.

1.66 M

Papers from low- and middle-income countries in 2023, more than eight times 2003: the map of who makes new knowledge has tilted toward poorer countries.

the numbers & method
Poorer countries' share of science papers tripled to half. Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators: Scientific and technical journal articles (IP.JRN.ARTC.SC), 2023.
Low and middle income (k)High income and other (k)
20031971,017
20084451,281
20136621,464
20189681,554
20231,6591,612

Claim types Fact · Interpretation

World Bank WDI indicator IP.JRN.ARTC.SC (original source: US National Science Foundation, NCSES, from Elsevier's Scopus database; articles counted by the country of the authors' institutions, split fractionally when authors come from several countries). Read from the World Bank API via the progrss vault (source wb-wdi, WDI edition 2026-10-08; GUIDELINES §4.11, 22 matching re-reads, no mismatch). Low- and middle-income = the World Bank aggregate 'Low & middle income' (LMY), which applies the current income classification to every year, so the same countries are counted at both ends. Articles, World (WLD): 1,213,775 (2003), 1,725,502 (2008), 2,125,848 (2013), 2,522,113 (2018), 3,271,296 (2023). Low & middle income: 197,172, 444,646, 662,127, 968,117, 1,659,400. 'High income and other' = World minus Low & middle income (progrss calculation; it includes the few economies the World Bank leaves unclassified). Shares are progrss calculations: 16.2% (2003), 25.8% (2008), 31.1% (2013), 38.4% (2018), 48.6% (2022), 50.7% (2023). China (upper-middle income): 87,586 articles in 2003 (7.2% of the world) and 932,712 in 2023 (28.5%), 56% of the group's 2023 total; low- and middle-income countries without China: 109,586 (9.0%) and 726,688 (22.2%). Other large risers 2003 to 2023: India 26,124 to 228,174, Iran 3,896 to 55,085, Indonesia 349 to 38,992, Egypt 3,547 to 22,854, Pakistan 1,458 to 20,519. Counts measure journal articles indexed in one database, not research quality or citations. Takeaway 3's second clause is Interpretation.

license this plate